A carpet cleaner sprays water and solution into carpet, scrubs it and sucks the dirty water back up, while a true steam cleaner, as an older Wirecutter guide describes it, uses a heating element to force steam through a nozzle. BISSELL’s FAQ says steam cleaners should be used for hard surfaces only, so BISSELL and Shaw point you to extraction for carpet.
The names blur, which is the real source of confusion. People often say “steam cleaning” for extraction, though Shaw says no steam is generated. BISSELL’s HydroSteam machines complicate things further: BISSELL says they add a built-in heater and steam, yet other BISSELL pages advise against steam on carpet. Check the manual for your exact model.
The two machines side by side
The clearest description comes from an older Wirecutter guide, republished by Engadget: extraction machines rely on hot tap water, formula and suction, while steam cleaners use heating elements to force steam through a pressurized nozzle.
| Carpet cleaner (extractor) | True steam cleaner | |
|---|---|---|
| How it cleans | Sprays water and solution, scrubs, then suctions dirty water back | Forces steam through a pressurized nozzle (older Wirecutter guide) |
| Heat source | Usually hot tap water; Rug Doctor says its rental machines have no heating element | A heating element (older Wirecutter guide) |
| Where makers point it | Carpet, rugs and, with tools, W or WS fabrics | Hard surfaces only, per BISSELL’s FAQ |
| Risk noted by sources | Over-wetting and residue, per Shaw | BISSELL says steam can damage carpet fibers and remove protection |
If you want the mechanics in detail, here’s how carpet cleaning machines work, stage by stage.
Why everyone says “steam cleaner” anyway
The term is common even among people who know better, and sources contradict each other about what home machines actually do:
- Shaw: hot water extraction is commonly called steam cleaning, although no steam is generated.
- Stanley Steemer: despite the name, it says it does not steam clean carpet and uses hot water extraction.
- Angi: calls home machines “steam cleaners” and says most have a built-in water heater.
- Rug Doctor: says its rental machines have no heating element, and to use hot tap water.
- BISSELL’s buying guide: says its carpet cleaners don’t heat water on their own, yet also suggests a “steam carpet cleaner” for a deeper clean.
So when a listing or a neighbor says “steam cleaner,” ask one question: does this model have a heater? Model pages and manuals are the place to check. Our guide to the best carpet steam cleaners sorts the machines that way.
What sources say about steam on carpet
Here the sources really do disagree, and no independent side-by-side test settled it in what we read.
- Against: BISSELL’s Berber guide says true steam cleaning is not recommended for carpets of any type. Which?, a UK tester, says steam cleaners are pretty poor at cleaning carpets. The older Wirecutter guide says extraction carries a lower risk of fabric damage, since its heat is limited to what the tap provides.
- For: Bob Vila’s FAQ favors a steam cleaner for deep cleaning carpet, though none of its tested picks is a steam model. Good Housekeeping says built-in heaters help remove stains.
Fibers and stains change the answer. On wool, BISSELL warns that steam can cause felting and shrinkage. On pet urine, CRI and Humane World warn against steam cleaners because heat can set the stain and smell, and PetMD gives similar advice. Against that, BISSELL markets the heated HydroSteam Pet for pet messes and cited a test using its urine formula. Advice on hot tap water is less clear, so check your formula’s label and consider using an enzyme product first.
Where BISSELL HydroSteam fits
HydroSteam machines sit between the two categories, and BISSELL’s own pages describe them differently. BISSELL’s HydroSteam article describes a built-in flow-through heater that turns water into steam, combined with water and solution. BISSELL’s FAQ, meanwhile, says a carpet cleaner doesn’t use steam. No steam temperature was published on the pages we read.
The manual for one model is the most useful wording. The BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam 3670F manual calls it primarily a carpet cleaner with a steam-cleaning feature, and warns not to touch the steam nozzle while using it. A Homes & Gardens review of the Revolution HydroSteam reports visible steam from the floorhead. So, by BISSELL’s own wording for that model, it’s still a carpet cleaner first.

Upright with a heater · Premium price range
BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam Pet
BISSELL lists Steam Pretreat and SteamWash Max Clean modes at 22.5 lb. Consumer Reports rated this 3432 model excellent for cleaning, but says the non-pet 4120 ranks at the bottom, so check the model number.
View product details ›
Portable with a heater · Mid-range price range
BISSELL Little Green HydroSteam Pet
BISSELL lists a built-in flow-through heater and a 64 oz clean tank at 13 lb. Reader’s Digest named it best with steam, and also found it the heaviest model it compared.
Check tools & attachments ›Heat isn’t the only thing to compare. Vacuum Wars measured the original HydroSteam Pet lowest of six BISSELL models on usable suction, and CNN Underscored called the upright very expensive.
Which one to use, and on what
Match the machine to the surface and the job, then let the manual have the final word:
| Job | What the sources point to |
|---|---|
| Wall-to-wall carpet | An extractor. Shaw’s care guide describes periodic hot water extraction for carpet |
| Sealed tile and grout | BISSELL lists its Little Green HydroSteam Pet for sealed hard floors, with a steam mode for grout and tile |
| Wood or laminate | Check the model. Rug Doctor’s Pro Deep guide says not to use it on or near wood or laminate |
| Fresh pet urine | Enzymatic cleaner, per ASPCA and VCA; avoid steam, per CRI and Humane World |
| Wool rugs | Read the manual first. BISSELL warns against steam; some manuals rule wool out |
Whichever label a machine carries, technique still counts. Our guide on how to use a carpet cleaner covers passes, dilution and drying.
Honest note
The word “steam” sells, but the sources don’t agree that it cleans carpet better. Good Housekeeping says heaters help with stains, Which? rates steam cleaners poorly on carpet, and BISSELL’s own pages disagree. We have not tested or used these carpet cleaners ourselves; specs are the brand’s own, and test findings belong to the publishers named.
Questions people ask
Is a carpet cleaner the same as a steam cleaner?
No. Most home carpet cleaners are hot water extractors that spray, scrub and suck water back up. Shaw notes that extraction is commonly called steam cleaning, although no steam is generated. A true steam cleaner uses a heating element, per an older Wirecutter guide.
Can I use a steam mop on carpet?
BISSELL advises against it. Its FAQ says steam cleaners should be used for hard surfaces only and that steam can damage carpet fibers and remove protection. Its Berber guide says true steam cleaning isn’t recommended for carpets of any type. Check your own mop’s manual too.
Is BISSELL HydroSteam a real steam cleaner?
BISSELL describes it as a carpet cleaner with heat and steam, not a steam cleaner alone. The Revolution HydroSteam 3670F manual calls it primarily a carpet cleaner with a steam-cleaning feature. BISSELL publishes no steam temperature on the pages we read, and its FAQ describes steam differently.
Should I use heat on pet urine?
Sources disagree, so be careful. CRI, Humane World and PetMD warn against steam cleaners on urine because heat can set the stain, while BISSELL markets its heated HydroSteam Pet for pet messes. Advice on hot tap water is less clear, so check your formula’s label.
Does steam help with fleas in carpet?
Don’t count on a carpet cleaner for fleas. EPA recommends steam cleaning carpets for fleas but doesn’t address home tap-water extractors, and Stanley Steemer says carpet cleaning can’t guarantee flea removal. Vacuuming is the first step EPA and CDC point to. Talk to your vet or a pest professional.
Read first: best carpet cleaner machine · best carpet steam cleaners
Sources: Shaw Floors: Carpet cleaning · BISSELL: Carpet cleaning FAQs · BISSELL: HydroSteam technology · BISSELL Revolution HydroSteam 3670F manual (ManualsLib) · Older Wirecutter guide via Engadget · Which?: How to buy the best carpet cleaner
Specifications and care instructions are each brand’s own. Follow your machine’s manual and your carpet maker’s care guide, test solution on a hidden spot first, and check before wet-cleaning wool or specialty rugs.



