Best Carpet Cleaner Machine · Upright

Best Upright Carpet Cleaner: Top Picks by Tank, Weight and Tools

The best upright carpet cleaner on independent stain results is the Shark CarpetXpert EX151: Vacuum Wars ranked it first, and Consumer Reports rated its cleaning excellent. It is light at about 16 lb but holds only about 0.6 gallon. Choose the Hoover SmartWash+ for the simplest use, or the BISSELL ProHeat 2X, our overall pick, if you want a bigger tank and a longer hose.

Upright carpet cleaner midway through a pass, leaving clean stripes on a beige carpet

Our top 3

Top picks at a glance

Best stain results#1
Shark CarpetXpert EX151 carpet cleaner

Shark CarpetXpert EX151

Mid-range price range

Vacuum Wars’ stain removal score of 90.1, against an 83.5 average. A smaller tank and a 5 ft hose.

Check tools ›
Simplest to use#2
Hoover SmartWash+ carpet cleaner

Hoover SmartWash+

Mid-range price range

Push to clean, pull to dry. CNN Underscored’s best upright and Bob Vila’s best overall.

Check tools ›
Best large upright#3
BISSELL Big Green PET PRO carpet cleaner

BISSELL Big Green PET PRO

Premium price range

Rental-style 1.75-gallon tanks and 48 oz of urine formula. Bob Vila’s best deep cleaner.

Check tools ›

In detail

Who each one suits

Specifications come from each brand, or from a retailer or reviewer where we name one. Test results belong to the publishers we name. We have not tested or used these machines ourselves.

Best stain results#1

Shark CarpetXpert EX151

The strongest independent stain numbers we found in a light machine. Vacuum Wars ranked it first on its list, with stain removal of 90.1 against an 83.5 average, and Consumer Reports said it performed excellent in its cleaning test. The compromise is capacity: about a 0.6-gallon tank and a short built-in hose.

Why it stands out

  • Vacuum Wars measured 12.4 kPa floor-head suction against a 7.26 average.
  • Consumer Reports rated cleaning excellent, and dryness and convenience very good.
  • The hose is built on, so spot cleaning needs little setup; a 25 ft cord per the Staples listing.
TypeLightweight upright
Clean tank0.6 gallon (Vacuum Wars, NBC Select)
WeightAbout 16 lb (Vacuum Wars measured 15.9 lb)
Hose5 ft built-in (Vacuum Wars)
HeatNone listed

Good fit if

  • You want strong stain results in a machine around 16 lb.
  • You want a built-in hose for quick spot work.
  • You clean average-sized rooms.

Skip it if

  • You clean large rooms: the small tank means more refills.
  • You need to reach stairs: Vacuum Wars found the 5 ft hose limiting.
  • You are noise sensitive: Consumer Reports rated noise fair.
Simplest to use#2

Hoover SmartWash+

The simplest upright to use. Push forward to clean, pull back to dry, with no trigger and automatic solution mixing. CNN Underscored named it best upright and Bob Vila its best overall. The drawback is spot work: you have to attach the hose and spray by hand.

Why it stands out

  • Hoover’s Auto Mix meters the solution, and pushing forward starts the cleaning function.
  • CNN Underscored found it matched the ProHeat on soy sauce, red wine and dirt within a few passes.
  • An 8 ft hose and a 12 in path (path width per the Target listing).
TypeFull-size upright
Clean tank1 gallon (Target listing)
Weight18.5 lb (Target listing)
Hose8 ft
HeatHeatForce drying air only

Good fit if

  • You want the least fuss, with no trigger and no measuring.
  • You clean open rooms and like a wider path.
  • You are happy to use Hoover’s own solutions.

Skip it if

  • You spot-treat often: CNN Underscored found you have to attach the hose and spray manually.
  • You want a sturdy feel: Bob Vila found the build less durable than other uprights.
  • You want a long cord: Good Housekeeping noted it is shorter than on some full-size models.
Best large upright#3

BISSELL Big Green PET PRO

A large, rental-style BISSELL aimed at pet homes. It carries 1.75-gallon tanks and comes with 48 oz of PET PRO OXY Urine Eliminator, far more formula than the usual trial bottles. Consumer Reports rated cleaning very good but noise poor, and it weighed 61 lb full in its tests.

Why it stands out

  • Clean and dirty tanks of 1.75 gallons each, so fewer refills on large stained areas.
  • A 9 ft hose and a 25 ft cord, with pet stain and stair tools.
  • Bob Vila named it its best deep cleaner, while noting its cost, weight and storage needs.
TypeLarge upright
Clean tank1.75 gallons
Weight44 lb
Hose9 ft
HeatNone; warm tap water

Good fit if

  • You deal with repeat pet accidents across several rooms.
  • You have floor-level storage for a 44 lb machine.
  • You would otherwise rent a large machine several times.

Skip it if

  • You have to carry it up stairs: Consumer Reports weighed it 61 lb full.
  • You are noise sensitive: Consumer Reports rated noise poor.
  • Your problem is one small spot: a portable is far lighter.
Also worth a look

BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus

A strong all-round choice for most homes: a full-size upright with a 1-gallon tank, an 8 ft hose and tools in the box. Consumer Reports rated it excellent for cleaning and very good for dryness, and NBC Select named it best overall upright. Hunker, citing Consumer Reports, lists the 3588F among its two top-rated full-size machines.

Why it stands out

  • Consumer Reports rated cleaning excellent and dryness very good.
  • BISSELL’s CleanShot targeted spray treats a spot as you go; CNN Underscored called it its favorite feature on this machine.
  • Includes 8 oz each of BISSELL’s PRO MAX and PET PRO OXY formulas, plus a stain tool and a pet upholstery tool.
TypeFull-size upright
Clean tank1 gallon
Weight17.5 lb
Hose8 ft
HeatHeatWave holds warm tap water; no heater

Good fit if

  • You want one machine for whole rooms, stairs and pet messes.
  • You can manage 17.5 lb empty (Consumer Reports weighed 28 lb full).
  • You want a hose and tools ready to use.

Skip it if

  • You expect a heater: BISSELL says this machine does not heat water; HeatWave only helps hold the temperature of the warm tap water you add.
  • You want easy brush upkeep: CNN Underscored found removing the rollers takes a screwdriver and removing the gear belt.
  • You rarely deal with pet hair: CNN Underscored found the premium hard to justify otherwise.
Also worth a look

BISSELL TurboClean Pet XL

A budget-friendly full-size machine for light soil and everyday spills. Vacuum Wars gave it a Best Budget badge and ranked it 9th of more than 30 models, with stain removal close to its tested average. It has a full 1-gallon tank and a 7 ft hose, but the small motor is its limit.

Why it stands out

  • Vacuum Wars scored stain removal at 82.7 against an 83.5 average.
  • 1-gallon clean and dirty tanks at 17 lb.
  • A 7 ft hose, a stain tool, a spraying crevice tool and two formula samples.
TypeFull-size upright
Clean tank1 gallon
Weight17 lb
Hose7 ft
HeatNone listed

Good fit if

  • You want full-size tanks and a hose at a lower price.
  • You mainly clean light soil and everyday spills.
  • You do not need heat.

Skip it if

  • You have heavily soiled carpet: Vacuum Wars measured below-average suction.
  • You want it for very dirty pet areas: its 6 amp motor sits under Vacuum Wars’ 8.93 tested average.
Also worth a look

Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe

A long-running value pick with a hose and three tools. NBC Select and HGTV both named it their value choice, and HGTV saw it fully clear smeared peanut butter. Consumer Reports disagrees on the main job, rating its cleaning only fair. Think of it as an everyday machine rather than a deep cleaner.

Why it stands out

  • An 8 ft hose (per Target) plus upholstery, crevice and stair tools.
  • Automatic mixing and HeatForce heated air for drying, per Hoover.
  • HGTV saw it remove red wine in two to three minutes.
TypeFull-size upright
Clean tank1 gallon (Target listing)
Weight18.1 lb (Target listing)
Hose8 ft (Target listing)
HeatHeatForce drying air only

Good fit if

  • You want a hose and tools at a lower price.
  • You mostly clean fresh spills.
  • You are comfortable with a larger machine.

Skip it if

  • Deep cleaning is the priority: Consumer Reports rated cleaning fair.
  • You dislike bulky machines: HGTV and CNN Underscored both flag its size or top-heavy handling.
  • You want more than a 2-year warranty.

Choosing between light and large?

See what owners say about the EX151’s tank size and built-in hose in real rooms.

Read owner reviews ›

Tips

Three things that make the difference

01

Weigh it full

Consumer Reports weighed the Shark EX151 at 21 lb full, the ProHeat at 28 lb and the Big Green PET PRO at 61 lb. Think about your stairs before you pick.

02

Expect noise

Consumer Reports found carpet cleaners averaged about 80 dBA, against up to 70 dB for a typical vacuum, and advises hearing protection. It rated the Big Green PET PRO poor for noise.

03

Look at the hose length

Hoses run from 5 ft on the EX151 to 9 ft on the Big Green models. If you want to do stairs or upholstery, Vacuum Wars found 5 ft limiting.

Honest note

Reviewers disagree, so no single upright wins everywhere. Vacuum Wars prefers the Shark EX151, CNN Underscored the SmartWash+ and NBC Select the ProHeat. Consumer Reports’ overall scores sit behind a paywall, so we can quote only its category ratings. Consider which results apply to your own rooms.

FAQ

Questions people ask

What is the best upright carpet cleaner?

On stain results we pick the Shark CarpetXpert EX151, which Vacuum Wars ranked first and Consumer Reports rated excellent for cleaning. It holds only about 0.6 gallon. For larger homes, the BISSELL ProHeat 2X has a 1-gallon tank and an 8 ft hose, and Consumer Reports also rated its cleaning excellent.

Bissell or Hoover: which upright is better?

It depends on the model. Consumer Reports rated the ProHeat 3588F excellent for cleaning, and the Hoover PowerDash Pet very good. CNN Underscored and Bob Vila prefer the Hoover SmartWash+ for simplicity, while Consumer Reports rated the Hoover PowerScrub Deluxe only fair for cleaning. Compare models rather than brands.

Which upright has the best suction?

Among those measured, Vacuum Wars reports 12.4 kPa at the floor head on the Shark EX151, against a 7.26 average, and 12.09 kPa usable suction on the BISSELL Big Green Machine, the top of its six-model BISSELL comparison. Different tests measure differently, so compare with care.

Which upright is easiest to use?

CNN Underscored says the Hoover SmartWash+ is designed around simplicity, and Bob Vila notes that pushing it forward turns on cleaning. Consumer Reports rated the ProHeat and the Shark EX151 very good for convenience. HGTV says its testers preferred tanks with fully removable lids.

How heavy are upright carpet cleaners?

On our list, from under 13 lb for the Hoover PowerDash Pet to 47 lb, per NBC Select, for the Rug Doctor Mighty Pro X3. Consumer Reports says a full tank adds 6 to 15 pounds to full-size models.

Do uprights work on stairs?

Only with a hose and a tool. The machine stays on the floor and the hose reaches up. The BISSELL ProHeat has an 8 ft hose, and the Big Green models 9 ft. The Hoover PowerDash Pet has none. Bissell also sells a 3-in-1 Stair Tool that sprays, scrubs and suctions from one rotating head.

Pick the upright you can actually lift

Want the full picture? See all our best carpet cleaner machine, compared by job, and the FAQ on formulas, drying and care.